Read the scene
Mark and Erica at the campus bar. Screenplay by Aaron Sorkin.
FROM THE BLACK WE HEAR--
MARK (V.O.)
Did you know there are more people with genius IQ’s living in China than there are people of any kind living in the United States?
ERICA (V.O.)
That can’t possibly be true.
MARK (V.O.)
It is.
ERICA (V.O.)
What would account for that?
MARK (V.O.)
Well, first, an awful lot of people live in China. But here’s my question:
FADE IN:
INT. CAMPUS BAR - NIGHT
MARK ZUCKERBERG is a sweet looking 19 year old whose lack of any physically intimidating attributes masks a very complicated and dangerous anger. He has trouble making eye contact and sometimes it’s hard to tell if he’s talking to you or to himself.
ERICA, also 19, is Mark’s date. She has a girl-next-door face that makes her easy to fall for. At this point in the conversation she already knows that she’d rather not be there and her politeness is about to be tested.
The scene is stark and simple.
MARK
How do you distinguish yourself in a population of people who all got 1600 on their SAT’s?
ERICA
I didn’t know they take SAT’s in China.
MARK
They don’t. I wasn’t talking about China anymore, I was talking about me.
ERICA
You got 1600?
MARK
Yes. I could sing in an a Capella group, but I can’t sing.
ERICA
Does that mean you actually got nothing wrong?
MARK
I can row crew or invent a 25 dollar PC.
ERICA
Or you can get into a final club.
MARK
Or I can get into a final club.
ERICA
You know, from a woman’s perspective, sometimes not singing in an a Capella group is a good thing?
MARK
This is serious.
ERICA
On the other hand I do like guys who row crew.
MARK
(beat)
Well I can’t do that.
ERICA
I was kid--
MARK
Yes, it means I got nothing wrong on the test.
ERICA
Have you ever tried?
MARK
I’m trying right now.
ERICA
To row crew?
MARK
To get into a final club. To row crew? No. Are you, like--whatever--delusional?
ERICA
Maybe, but sometimes you say two things at once and I’m not sure which one I’m supposed to be aiming at.
MARK
But you’ve seen guys who row crew, right?
ERICA
No.
MARK
Okay, well they’re bigger than me. They’re world class athletes. And a second ago you said you like guys who row crew so I assumed you had met one.
ERICA
I guess I just meant I liked the idea of it. The way a girl likes cowboys.
MARK
(beat)
Okay.
ERICA
Should we get something to eat?
MARK
Would you like to talk about something else?
ERICA
No, it’s just since the beginning of the conversation about finals club I think I may have missed a birthday.
(can’t get over it)
There are really more people in China with genius IQ’s than the entire population of--
MARK
The Phoenix is the most diverse. The Fly Club, Roosevelt punched the Porc.
ERICA
Which one?
MARK
The Porcellian, the Porc, it’s the best of the best.
ERICA
Which Roosevelt?
MARK
Theodore.
ERICA
Is it true that they send a bus around to pick up girls who want to party with the next Fed Chairman?
MARK
You can see why it’s so important to get in.
ERICA
Okay, well, which is the easiest to get into?
MARK is visibly hit by that...
MARK
Why would you ask me that?
ERICA
I’m just asking.
MARK
None of them, that’s the point. My friend Eduardo made $300,000 betting oil futures one summer and Eduardo won’t come close to getting in. The ability to make money doesn’t impress anybody around here.
ERICA
Must be nice. He made $300,000 in a summer?
MARK
He likes meteorology.
ERICA
You said it was oil futures.
MARK
You can read the weather you can predict the price of heating oil. I think you asked me that because you think the final club that’s easiest to get into is the one where I’ll have the best chance.
ERICA
I asked--what?
MARK
You asked me which one was the easiest to get into because you think that that’s the one where I’ll have the best chance.
ERICA
The one that’s the easiest to get into would be the one where anybody has the best chance.
MARK
You didn’t ask me which one was the best one, you asked me which one was the easiest one.
ERICA
I was honestly just asking. Okay? I was just asking to ask. Mark, I’m not speaking in code.
MARK
Erica--
ERICA
You’re obsessed with finals clubs. You have finals clubs OCD and you need to see someone about it who’ll prescribe you some sort of medication. You don’t care if the side effects may include blindness.
MARK
Final clubs. Not finals clubs and there’s a difference between being obsessed and being motivated.
ERICA
Yes there is.
MARK
Well you do--that was cryptic--so you do speak in code.
ERICA
I didn’t mean to be cryptic.
MARK
I’m saying I need to do something substantial in order to get the attention of the clubs.
ERICA
Why?
MARK
Because they’re exclusive. And fun and they lead to a better life.
ERICA
Teddy Roosevelt didn’t get elected president because he was a member of the Phoenix Club.
MARK
He was a member of the Porcellian and yes he did.
ERICA
Well why don’t you just concentrate on being the best you you can be?
MARK
Did you really just say that?
ERICA
(beat)
I was kidding.
ERICA (CONT'D)
Although just because something’s trite it doesn’t make it any less--
MARK
I want to try to be straight forward with you and tell you that I think you might want to be a little more supportive. If I get in I’ll be taking you...to the events, and the gatherings...and you’ll be meeting a lot of people you wouldn’t normally get to meet.
ERICA
(smiles)
You would do that for me?
MARK
We’re dating.
ERICA
Okay, well I want to try and be straight forward with you and let you know that we’re not anymore.
MARK
What do you mean?
ERICA
We’re not dating anymore, I’m sorry.
MARK
Is this a joke?
ERICA
No, it’s not.
MARK
You’re breaking up with me?
ERICA
You’re going to introduce me to people I wouldn’t normally have the chance to meet? What the fff--What is that supposed to mean?
MARK
Wait, settle down.
ERICA
What is it supposed to mean?
MARK
Erica, the reason we’re able to sit here and drink right now is cause you used to sleep with the door guy.
ERICA
The door guy, his name is Bobby. I did not slept with the door guy, the door guy is a friend of mine. He’s a perfectly good class of people and what part of Long Island are you from--Wimbledon?
MARK
Wait--
ERICA
I’m going back to my dorm.
MARK
Wait, wait, is this real?
ERICA
Yes.
MARK
Okay, then wait. I apologize, okay?
ERICA
I have to go study.
MARK
Erica--
ERICA
Yeah.
MARK
I’m sorry, I mean it.
ERICA
I appreciate that but--
MARK
Come on.
ERICA
--I have to study.
MARK
You don’t have to study. You don’t have to study. Let’s just talk.
ERICA
I can’t.
MARK
Why?
ERICA
Because it’s exhausting. Dating you is like dating a stairmaster.
MARK
All I meant is that you’re not likely to-- currently--I wasn’t making a comment on your parents--I was just saying you go to B.U., I was stating a fact, that’s all, and if it seemed rude then of course I apologize.
ERICA
I have to go study.
MARK
You don’t have to study.
ERICA
Why do you keep saying I don’t have to study?!
MARK
Because you go to B.U.!
ERICA stares at him...
MARK (CONT’D)
(pause)
Do you want to get some food?
ERICA
I’m sorry you’re not sufficiently impressed with my education.
MARK
And I’m sorry I don’t have a rowboat so we’re even.
ERICA
I think we should just be friends.
MARK
I don’t want friends.
ERICA
I was being polite, I have no intention of being friends with you.
MARK
I’m under some pressure right now with my OS class and if we could just order food I think we should--
ERICA takes MARK’s hand and looks at him tenderly...
ERICA
(close)
You are probably going to be a very successful computer person.
ERICA (CONT'D)
But you’re going to go through life thinking that girls don’t like you because you’re a nerd. And I want you to know, from the bottom of my heart, that that won’t be true. It’ll be because you’re an asshole.
And with that stinger, ERICA walks off we slowly push in on MARK. A fuse has just been lit.
Two people, two different conversations
Mark and Erica are on a date in a campus bar. In the opening pages, talk moves between test scores, rowing and selective university clubs. For rehearsal, try giving them different immediate needs: one wants to be admired; the other wants a conversation she can share.
Those needs are working interpretations. Start by pursuing them rather than illustrating a personality. Trying to win someone's approval gives an actor something to check in the other person's face. Playing clever for the whole scene can leave that face irrelevant.
Find the meaning that triggers the reply
On PDF page 5, printed page 4, Erica asks about the easiest club to enter. The script explicitly gives Mark a reaction to that question. He treats it as a judgement of his chances; she tries to explain that she was asking a straightforward question.
Give the actor playing Mark a private paraphrase of what he thinks he has heard. For example: you don't think I belong. Say it silently, then use the written reply. Erica's actor should know her own reason for asking, without taking responsibility for the interpretation he supplies.
The useful tension comes from those two meanings meeting. If both actors agree beforehand that the question is an obvious insult, they remove the misunderstanding they need to play.
Playing Mark: let the answer matter
Try an opening objective of getting Erica to recognise your ambition. Listen for the response that would satisfy you. Does interest in the subject count, or do you need her to agree that it is important? That distinction can change how you receive the same question.
On a second run, try to recruit her to your future. This may make a correction feel helpful to you even as it becomes hurtful to her. Stay interested in making the attempt succeed. The scene loses pressure if you start each line intending to prove that Mark is unpleasant.
When an attempt fails, change the action. Explain, challenge, reassure or bargain as the exchange gives you reason. Choose the verb after noticing what happened, rather than attaching a different performance colour to every line.
Playing Erica: give patience a purpose
Erica's opening description says that her politeness is being tested. That is useful context, but it does not require you to demonstrate contempt from the first word. Try to get through to him, make room for yourself or bring the conversation back to something shared.
Choose one practical sign that would persuade you he has heard you. It might be an answer to the question you actually asked, or a moment of interest in what matters to you. Let each failed attempt affect how much effort you are prepared to make next.
Avoid arranging a steady rise in irritation. An actor can become more direct, quieter or briefly warmer in pursuit of the same aim. Test the choice against the text and your partner's response. The audience does not need a signal for every change.
Notice when the job changes
On PDF page 7, printed page 6, Mark's offer of access to social events is followed by Erica ending the relationship. On PDF page 8, printed page 7, he apologises and tries to keep her there. Those events give the actors a clear change of task.
Before that turn, you may be trying to win agreement about the future. Afterwards, you may be trying to prevent an immediate departure. Test the difference without automatically changing volume. The same calm delivery can serve a new, urgent purpose.
Put a light pencil mark at the point where the old action stops working. At the next run, allow your partner to make that failure happen. A mark should remind you what to investigate, rather than command a pause at a fixed syllable.
Earn the pace
Begin at a pace where each actor can finish hearing a thought. Once the chain is clear, shorten the time between hearing, interpreting and replying. Keep the exact wording available as the pace increases.
Choose one exchange and ask each actor what prompted their entrance. A specific misunderstanding, correction or refusal is a stronger cue than the knowledge that it is now your turn. If you cannot name what you are responding to, slow that exchange down and reconnect it.
Do not add interruptions simply to make the scene sound busy. Check where the script already breaks or continues a thought, and work from the same copy. You can investigate overlapping speech without losing the information the next response needs.
A conversation-repair exercise
Choose a short stretch around the club question, keeping enough of the preceding exchange to understand it. Work with a partner and allow about fifteen minutes. Use the written dialogue for each run. The notes between runs are your own words.
- First run: play the exchange at an unhurried pace. Afterwards, each actor writes what they wanted and what they believed the other person meant. Compare the notes without trying to reconcile the two interpretations.
- Second run: give each actor one way to repair the exchange. One might try to make the question sound ordinary; the other might try to secure reassurance. Keep the dialogue unchanged and notice whether the repair reaches its intended target.
- Third run: keep the clearest objectives and increase the pace. Allow a tactic to fail before replacing it. Afterwards, identify one response you genuinely heard differently and the line where it altered your next attempt.
Prepare your side before meeting a partner
Mark the thought you are responding to beside a handful of entrances. Separate the words you actually hear from the meaning your character gives them. That small distinction can keep a familiar exchange open to a new reading.
For spoken practice in Action, import an authorised script, check the detected scenes and roles, then choose your character while the app reads the other parts. Use those runs to secure the words and test entrances. Bring the choices back to a human partner to explore the mutual misunderstandings.
Keep the screenplay and performance distinct
This study uses an undated screenplay copy credited to Aaron Sorkin. The opening bar encounter runs from PDF page 2 to Erica's departure on PDF page 10, counting the title page as page 1. The following script pages carry printed numbers 2 to 9.
The objectives and exercises here are proposed rehearsal choices. They are not accounts of how the film's actors prepared the scene. Read your copy before watching a performance, then describe any choice you observe in terms you can investigate yourself.
Rehearse your next scene
Bring a script you are authorised to use, choose your role and run the lines aloud with Action reading the other parts.
Download Action on the App Store